4.5 The Geoengineering Dilemma

Now we’re getting into some real interesting stuff.  Geoengineering!  Let’s take a look at what our options are for artificially manipulating the climate to suit our needs.

C02 Removal

C02 Removal is pretty self-explanatory – this is an attempt to remove greenhouse gas from the atmosphere to cool the planet.  For instance, mixing a calcium hydroxide solution with water that has a lot of dissolved C02 will cause a chemical reaction which will form calcium carbonate, effectively removing C02 from the carbon cycle.

Another form of C02 removal is using biological processes (photosynthesis, etc.)  Probably the most practical option for C02 removal is using biofuels for energy production (such as the Prax generators in the UK using woodchips for their steam generation) – although I’m not sure how this is “removal” rather than just “carbon neutral.”  One final method is called ‘biochar,’ which sounds pretty cool but essentially just boils down to producing char coal from a lot of biomass (read: trees), but this method requires a lot of land to achieve.

It should be noted that CO2 removal can only be used to reduce global warming, not to reverse it, since we are never going to be able to take more carbon out of the atmospthere than we are putting in.

Solar Radiation Management

Another form of geoengineering is solar radiation management.  This is essentially just introducing aerosols into the atmosphere to control how much solar radiation reaches the surface – the less solar radiation, the less warming of the surface.  This has been discussed in some capacity and has given the chemtrail conspiracy theorists something to point at to “validate” their claims (I really, REALLY cannot stand chemtrail conspiracy theorists).  At any rate, the specific example given was to introduce a “few megatons” of sulfur dioxide into the upper atmosphere using balloons or aircraft, which would form tiny droplets of highly reflective sulfuric acid (which to me sounds like a bad idea to have a few megatons of sulfuric acid just floating around, but smarter people than me are proposing this).  The increased reflectivity of the atmosphere would increase the overall albedo of the earth and thereby counteract the effects of global warming.

So what are the drawbacks, besides conspiracy theorists having a heyday?

If our solar radiation management system were to ever stop working due to economic reasons or otherwise, we would be left with a very high concentration of C02 in the atmosphere and no way to mitigate the greenhouse effect caused by it.  This would cause a very sudden and severe spike in global temperatures, which would needless to say be devastating to the ecosystems.

Furthermore, there would inevitably be negative effects in certain localized weather patterns which we would not be able to control.  This part gets a little interesting, because the changed weather patterns would end up benefitting some regions, but being a detriment to others.  Thinking about this a bit gives me a bit of a feeling of a crazy James Bond villain who manipulates the weather to make the UK extremely arid, while making his home country a tropical paradise or something to that effect.  Oh, and using aerosols to control climate would also probably cause the polar ice caps to still melt, while keeping the populated regions of the earth at normal temperatures, so that would probably not be a great thing overall.

4.1 Making future projections and modelling future scenarios

This week started off with a discussion of climate change modelling, which as an engineer and general science nerd interests me a good bit.  The Met Office in the UK is a leader in climate change modelling (thank goodness they aren’t in the US, because I’m sure they’d be defunded at this point).

At any rate, apparently modelling climate change over the long term is pretty similar in concept to modelling weather in the short term, with the main difference being the fact that you need to account for variables that you wouldn’t otherwise when you’re modelling in the long term, such as

  • changing of ocean currents
  • changes in the heat transfer patters of the ocean
  • carbon storage rates in vegetation

Climate change models attempt to break down the earth in to different ‘boxes’ or systems, which all interact with one another.  For instance, the ocean currents and heat transfer patterns are modelled using well-established Navier-Stokes equations (hey, I studied those!).

navier-stokes

Other systems, such as the rate of carbon absorption into the biosphere, lithosphere, etc are not as well defined and I’m assuming this is the area that different climate models differ the most.

Climate change models typically take about 3 months to run completely through on the Met Office servers (one has to wonder what the students/scientists do while the simulation is running – do they just enjoy themselves?  Perhaps I should switch my career path)

How do we know these models can be trusted?

Like any good simulation, they are validated by comparing their results with demonstrated real-world results.  In other words, they are compared with history!  As it turns out, if we completely remove human factors from these models, we can successfully simulate the world’s climate up until about 1970, at which point the historical data starts to diverge from models which remove human factors.  And interestingly, the climate actually should be cooling if humans were not messing with the earth’s systems.

Even accounting for the uncertainty of the models, we can conclude that there is at least a 90% chance that humans are the driving cause of the warming of the earth.

So what does it mean for the future?

Well, the short answer is, we don’t know for certain, other than the fact that the earth will continue to get warmer.  There are many variables that are complete unknowns which make it hard to predict the future, such as

  • human population
  • energy production methods
  • absorption of CO2 by the biosphere, lithosphere and hydrosphere

Given the unknowns, the best solution is to simulate a wide variety of scenarios, to help us understand the range of possible outcomes.  By doing this, we get an optimistic prediction of leveling off climate change at 2 degrees Celsius increase over baseline levels (assuming swift, effective action – which does not look likely) and a pessimistic prediction of 6 degrees Celsius over baseline levels within the next 100 years.

Guys, I live in North Carolina.  I do not want to think of what it would be like here when it’s on average 6 degrees Celsius warmer than it already is.  It’s freaking hot here.

Anyway, that’s all I got for this section of Week 4.  See you next time!

Week 3

OK, so this week I’ve been very busy and unable to keep up with the blog for my class, so I am going to cover the whole week with one post.  And that’s OK, I think, because this week seemed hard to blog about.  Let’s do this.

3.1 Signs of Climate Change

This short video covered the modern signs that indicate that our climate is changing.  This includes in recent history when temperatures have been measured globally over the land and ocean, as well as recorded sea levels.  The rise in sea levels is caused ~50% by thermal expansion, and ~50% by melting glaciers and Greenland losing ice mass.  Interestingly, sea ice melting is not a factor that causes a rise in sea levels because the sea ice already displaces the same amount of water that it contains (which makes sense if you understand buoyancy).

3.2 How Has Our Climate Changed?

This section brings us to Met Office, which is a good resource to show recent trends in temperature across the globe.  Since this is more or less showing the same trend as the famous “hockey stick,” I’m just going to leave the link for you and not add a ton of discussion about it.

3.3 State of the Climate: Extreme Events

This website provides a record of extreme weather events across the globe – we were to discuss the extreme weather events closest to the place where we live – in my case, the US.

The U.S. saw the 2nd hottest year on record (the hottest being 2012). That’s some pretty clear evidence in favor of climate change, given the recency of the 1st and 2nd hottest years.

Regarding the Antarctic sea ice levels in 2011 and 2012: there is much more variation in sea ice levels than previously seen. 2011 shows record low sea ice coverage during the summer, but very high sea ice coverage during the winter. 2012 shows an all-time record high. A couple of these events would seem to disagree with the conclusion that the earth is warming overall on average, but the earth is not a simple system. Various locations will see various changes in climate, some may even buck the trend. However, the instances of extremes one way or the other all in a short amount of time would also suggest that the climate is seeing changes that it hasn’t before, and/or that the various feedback loops that regulate the climate are being thrown out of whack.

If there were no climate change at all, one would not expect to see such wild variations in the Antarctic ice over a short amount of time.

3.4 Your Warming World

Here is another resource to investigate climate change.

We were asked to discuss:

“What can you find out about the places on Earth which have experienced the largest warming from 1980-2004? Are you also able to discover whether the areas which are experiencing the most warming are also showing the largest variability in temperature and/or precipitation?”

Interestingly, the places on earth that appear to have warmed the most from 1980-2004 are in the northern hemisphere – particularly the northernmost parts of the northern hemisphere.  The countries with the most warming from 1980-2004 are Canada, Russia, and Greenland (and the North Pole, which isn’t a country, but wouldn’t that be cool if it was?)  There is also a band that stretches over the Sahara and the Middle East that shows a high amount of warming over that period.

The countries/regions that are experiencing the most warming also appear to be experiencing the most variability in temperatures, but only in the winter months.  During the summer, there is low variability.  I can say from anecdotal experience that this appears to be true for where I live.

3.6 Our Changing Carbon Cycle

This short video was packed with a lot of information, which I’ll try to summarize here.

  • The climate has changed dramatically over the last 100-150 years, mostly driven by anthropomorphic CO2 (sound familiar?)
  • This all started around 1750, when the steam engine was developed, and subsequently caused economies to be driven by the burning of fossil fuels.
  • 10 petagrams (1 petagram = 10^15 grams!) of CO2 are released into the atmosphere every year by anthropomorphic activity.
  • Of those 10 petagrams, only 4.5 stay in the atmosphere – the rest are absorbed into the oceans and the land.  The increased CO2 in the atmosphere drives an increased amount of photosynthesis from plants, which thereby removes the CO2 from the atmosphere and produces oxygen.  Oceans absorb a lot of CO2 from the atmosphere by dissolving it from the air.
  • We crossed the 400 ppm milestone for CO2 in the atmosphere in 2013.

 

3.7 Global Carbon Emissions

This lesson showed yet another awesome resource that has measurements for carbon emissions of most (all?) countries over the last 50 or so years.  I plotted the emissions of a handful of countries with different economic histories and backgrounds on a per capita basis – you can see the graph here.

Not surprisingly, the US has led in emissions for almost the entire history here. Saudi Arabia has recently overtaken us (yay?) and there has been a small trend of reduced emissions in the last decade.  I don’t know if that will continue, given *ahem* recent events in the country.  Other interesting notes are that France and Germany have been steadily decreasing emissions per capita.  You can also see increases or decreases relating to certain specific events, such as the fall of the Soviet Union in Russia leading to decreased emissions (which probably is due to a struggling economy) for example.  On the other hand, France and Germany’s decreased emissions are likely due to a focus on renewables and nuclear energy.

Finally, not surprisingly, Ethiopia barely even registers for carbon emissions, but it is still interesting to note that their emissions on a per capita basis have risen 10 times since 1960.  On one hand, that’s the most dramatic increase of any country I included in the study save Saudi Arabia, but on the other hand, it is very easy to increase your totally many fold when you start at nearly zero.

 

OK, that’s it for week 3, save the test, reflection, and another discussion or two.  On to the test!

2.8 Reflect

Another week down in Climate Change: Challenges and Solutions.  There are 5 questions to reflect on, so let’s get to it:

  • What are the most important themes you have learned this week?

I think the most important thing I learned this week was how scientists use proxy data to determine what past climates were like.  This is the process that a lot of people don’t understand and assume that scientists cannot “know” what the temperature of the earth was before we started directly recording it.  If more people understood these proxy data sources and what information we can garner from them, they would likely be more apt to believe the conclusion that the earth is in fact warming at an unprecedented rate.

  • What aspect of this week did you find difficult?

I did not find any of the concepts presented this week to be difficult.

  • What did you find most interesting? And why?

The thing I found most interesting is the effect aerosols have on climate.  I think most people assume “aerosols=bad,” but they actually have been counteracting the overall temperature increase due to increased greenhouse gases, and if there weren’t anthropogenic aerosols in the atmosphere, we would likely be in a worse position in terms of temperature increase than we are today.

An honorary mention goes to the fact that we can directly track temperature changes in Earth’s history by measuring temperatures in different layers of ice sheets.  The temperatures of the ice sheets is still directly related to the temperature of the earth at the time they were formed!  The whole concept is like a temperature time capsule, which is pretty cool (no pun intended).

  • Was there something that you learned this week that prompted you to do your own research?

Not yet, however it did take a lot of concepts that I was only somewhat familiar with and gave me a much greater understanding of them.  In particular, I came to a greater understanding of what aerosols are and how they interact with our environment and ultimately affect climate.  I am intrigued at the thought that there are many different types of aerosol, each of which has a different overall effect on the climate and many are relatively under-studied.

  • Are there any web sites or other online resource that you found particularly useful in furthering your knowledge and understanding?

I found NASA’s earth observatory section on aerosols to be particularly informative.  I hadn’t really known about that section of the NASA website before.

2.4 Recent past climate change

In today’s video, we learned about the medieval village Hound Tor, and how short term changes in climate caused the village to cease to exist a mere few hundred years later.  We also examine what natural factors that affect climate change, as well as various indicators we have for recording the weather and overall climate.

Natural Factors Affecting Climate Change

I like this part, because I’m an engineer and a space nerd, and it involves variables, periods, and the orbit of earth.

E = eccentricity

eccentricity

Eccentricity is a term that describes how elliptical or circular the orbit of a planet is – in this case, we’re referring to Earth.  The eccentricity of Earth’s orbit increases and decreases over time, with a period of about 100,000 years.  As the earth gets closer to the sun while it has a higher eccentricity, it sees more solar energy than during parts of the year where it is farther than the sun.  In periods when the Earth’s orbit is more circular, the Earth sees nearly equal amounts of solar energy throughout the year.

T = obliquity

obliquity

Obliquity refers to the angle of the Earth’s axis in relation to the axis that is perpendicular to the plane of the Earth’s orbit.  Or, more simply put, the tilt of the earth.  This can vary between 21.5 degrees and 24.5 degrees and has a period of 41,000 years.  The tilt of the Earth affect which parts of the surface see more or less sunlight throughout the year.

P = precession

Precession refers to the wobble of the axis of the earth.  As the earth spins, it wobbles like a top on the axis.  The amount of precession the earth sees has a period of 23,000 years.

All of these factors together have an effect on the climate of the earth.

Natural Indicators of Climate Through the Years

There are a few ways we can see what the climate was like before we started recording it.  Among them are ice cores and tree ring studies.  The picture below is a (poor) representation of a bored out piece of a tree trunk:

tree-ring-study

Tree ring studies involve pulling a core out of a tree and seeing the distance between the rings to determine how much sun a tree got in a given year.  More width between the rings means more growth, and therefore more sun.  Less width means the opposite.  This tells us how the climate has changed over the years in the trees life span.  We can also look at wood samples from dead trees and correlate their later years with living trees to see even further back into the past.  Comparing the data of many trees gives us a reliable look at what the weather and climate was like in recent history.

So what drove people away from Hound Tor?

Volcanic eruptions, most likely.  Volcanic activity presents the most unpredictable changes in climate over short term periods.  When volcanoes erupt, they spread ash and aerosols into wide areas of the atmosphere, which can drastically affect the amount of solar radiation reaching the earth, and therefore the temperature.  An eruption at Mount Pinatubo, for example, caused the world’s temperatures to drop 0.5 degrees Celsius all on its own!

What does all of this tell us?

In examining the recent history of climate on the earth, we get a sudden sharp rise in temperature over the last 100-150 years that can’t be explained by natural factors.  When we look at the rise in temperature along with the rise in the amount of C02 in the atmosphere (which is almost entirely driven by human activity), the rise in temperature directly corresponds to the rise in CO2.

2017-02-09 (1).png

The lesson this week concludes with a stark reminder of what climate change did to the people of Hound Tor, and what it may do in the future on a much larger scale.

 

2.1 Ancient past climate change

 

Today’s video was very interesting!  Not that the others haven’t been, but we are entering unfamiliar territory for me.  Today, we examined two key questions about the history of Earth’s climate:

Why has the earth had liquid water as early as 4.2 billion years ago?

The earth was formed 4.5 billion years ago, when the sun was 25-30% dimmer than it is today (because the sun is constantly getting brighter and larger and will eventually consume the earth, nbd).  With today’s atmosphere, a 25-30% dimmer sun would mean that the earth would be a giant winter wonderland.

So why was there liquid water 4.2 billion years ago?  Well, the earth had a much thicker atmosphere with higher concentrations of CO2 and water vapor.  This caused the earth to be warmer than it is today, despite the dimmer sunlight.

This begs the question, where did all of the extra CO2 in the atmosphere go?  Why, into the rocks, of course.  No, really.  The CO2 was absorbed by water in the atmosphere, which formed carbonic acid, which precipitated and dissolved silicate rocks and ran off into the ocean.  From there, the silicate solution was transferred into the biosphere in the form of shells.  The shells are then deposited into the lithosphere (ocean floor) in the form of carbonate rocks.

So let’s recap: all of the extra atmosphere was absorbed by water, reacted with rocks, used by marine life, then deposited into the ocean floor.  A large part of the former atmosphere is now a bunch of rocks.  That’s pretty cool.  All of this re-allocation of C02 molecules resulted in a negative feedback.  Had the atmosphere stayed the same as it was 4.2 billion years ago, we’d all be pretty sweaty right about now.

Ok, that’s one mystery solved.  On to the next.

What’s with those random ice ages, and why aren’t we still in one?

Over the years, the re-allocation of C02 described above acted to cool the earth.  Also, the amount of land exposed above the sea increased in this time, which sped up the removal of C02 from the atmosphere further.  The cooling of the earth increased glacier size, which we already learned last week is a positive feedback loop, because glaciers have a high albedo, which further decreases temperature due to less radiation being absorbed by the earth.  So, it’s been determined that when glaciers reach 30 degrees latitude from the poles, the positive feedback of cooling produces a runaway effect, turning the earth into a giant snowball.  This has already happened in earth’s history, five times!

So, why isn’t the earth permanently a giant snowball? 

If the earth is completely covered by glaciers, there is no way for the CO2 to be re-allocated from the atmosphere to the lithosphere, because there are no exposed rocks to weather and carry silicate to the ocean.  Meanwhile, C02 is being put into the atmosphere by volcanic activity, and because there is no way for it to be regulated, it constantly builds up, until the earth becomes warm enough to melt the glaciers covering the entire surface.

This repetition of extremes from “hot planet” to “cold” planet will eventually cease to occur due to the fact that the sun is constantly getting brighter, and eventually the earth will be outside of the habitable zone of the sun.  That’s going to be a big problem, to put it lightly.

Well there you have it.  2.1 done!

1.10 Reflect (alternatively, have a high albedo)

I have completed the first week of Climate Change: Challenges and Solutions.  I know, super impressive.  I got an 80% on my first test (12 of 15), which is ok, I guess.  Now it’s time to REFLECT.

  • What are the key scientific principles that explain climate change including the greenhouse (blanket) effect?

The key scientific principles are relating to solar radiation and what happens to it once it reaches earth.  Albedo refers to how much light (or solar radiation) is reflected by the surface of the earth.  Ice, for example reflects a lot of light and is said to have a high albedo.  Water absorbs a lot of solar radiation and is said to have a low albedo.  Obviously, since the earth is covered with mostly water, this means that the earth has a low overall albedo (around 30%).

The high absorption of solar radiation tends to raise the temperature of the earth, which is in general a good thing, because otherwise we’d all be freezing.

  • What are the key feedback mechanisms that help to explain why our climate is able to “self-regulate”?

There are many feedback loops that exist in the climate system that all play a certain role.  Some key ones are:

The water vapor feedback loop – this is a positive feedback loop which occurs when water is turned into water vapor from solar radiation.  Once it is vapor, it enters the atmosphere and absorbs more radiation.  It heats up, and gives off radiation in all directions, including back down to the surface, which in turn heats up the surface and causes more water to evaporate, and so on.

The ice albedo feedback loop – This is another positive feedback loop.  As solar radiation interacts with ice on the surface, some of it will melt into water.  Because there is now less ice, the surface will have a lower albedo (less reflected solar radiation), which will cause more radiation to be absorbed, and therefore leading to increased temperatures, which will melt more ice, and so on.

The radiation feedback loop – This is a negative feedback loop.  As I understand it, objects tend to give off more radiation the more they heat up.  Therefore, if an object is taking in heat, the hotter it gets, the more heat it will give off.

  • How can our climate be conceptualized as a system containing a series of components that interact with one another?

You can break climate down into a system by looking at separate components in the system that all have a certain effect on it.  These are:

The hydrosphere
The biosphere
The lithosphere
The atmosphere
The cryosphere

Each of these interact with each other in various ways and all affect the climate.  For example, water from the ocean (which has an albedo that affects climate) will naturally evaporate due to solar radiation and turn into water vapor (which is a greenhouse gas).  The water vapor is now in the atmosphere and eventually will condense and fall back to the earth as precipitation, re-joining the hydrosphere or cryosphere if it freezes.  Water vapor can also come from the biosphere or the lithosphere as well.

I’m sure that we’ve only touched on a TINY fraction of the feedback loops and the various ways the different components of the climate system interact, and I’m looking forward to expanding my knowledge of them!  There we have it, week 1 complete.

1.7 The Climate System, Feedbacks, Cycles, and Self-Regulation

Earth’s Climate as a System

Today’s video in Climate Change: Challenges and Solutions introduced the concept of defining Earth’s climate as a system, which has 5 key components that are all connected:

  • The atmosphere – the air around Earth
  • The hydrosphere – the oceans, rivers, lakes, etc
  • The biosphere – all life on earth
  • The cryosphere – frozen water in the form of glaciers, snow, ice caps
  • The lithosphere – Earth’s crust

The best display of the connection between these components of the climate system is shown by looking at the hydrosphere – solar radiation evaporates a certain amount of water from the hydrosphere and biosphere (plants), and the water enters the atmosphere as water vapor.  Once the water is in the atmosphere it eventually condenses and falls back to the surface and returns to either the hydrosphere or the cryosphere if it is frozen.

Three Key Feedback Loops

The next important point in this video is the idea of feedback loops within the climate system.  There were three discussed:

Water vapor feedback

Water feedback.PNG

 

The idea here is that water gets evaporated by solar radiation and escapes the hydrosphere (oceans, etc) into the atmosphere.  The water vapor in the atmosphere absorbs heat energy reflected from the surface, and actually re-emits a portion of this energy BACK to the earth’s surface, resulting in more heating at the surface, resulting in more water vapor entering the atmosphere, and so on.  This is a positive feedback.

Ice Albedo Feedback

In the ice albedo feedback loop, we must remember that albedo means the amount of radiation which is reflected back from the surface of the Earth.  Ice has a high albedo (I had to stop myself from writing ‘libido,’ but anyway), and reflects a lot of radiation back into space.  Water has a low albedo.

As ice melts, it makes the surface have a lower overall albedo, which in turn heats the earth more due to less radiation being reflected back into space, and so on.  Simple!  The Ice Albedo Feedback loop is another positive feedback.

Radiation Feedback

This one is maybe the least intuitive to me.  Here, the idea is that as a body of matter heats up, it gives off more radiation (an example of this is a hot coal glowing red).  The hotter the object gets, the more radiation it gives off, which in turns cools it.  So as it heats, it cools?  This is a negative feedback.

Alright, that’s it for this one!  On to the next video.

 

 

Climate Change: Challenges and Solutions

Partially because of all of the science illiteracy running rampant in my country, I decided to take a course on climate change so that I may better explain the phenomenon and to be able to converse about it intelligently.

And, the course is asking me to create a blog to facilitate reflective and social learning, so here we are!  I’ll be recapping what I’ve learned and engaging in conversation with others about their thoughts & ideas in this space.  So, let’s get started.

1.1 Key Principles of Climate Change

This was a short video that mostly recapped what I already know of greenhouse gases (side note, my wife just informed me that ‘gases’ has one s, rather than two, she’s an English major).  During this first video, an alternative name for the greenhouse gas phenomenon was presented – ‘the blanket effect.’  Basically, the blanket effect is a more correct analogy for what we all know as the greenhouse gas effect due to the fact that the main cause of heat in a greenhouse is that the air is trapped inside, and not allowed to convect as it normally would otherwise.  This is not the case for so-called greenhouse gases – they behave more like a blanket in that they trap the heat from short wave radiation near the surface by reflecting it back on the surface.

We also learned about “albedo,” which is the amount of reflected radiation from the surface.  Different areas of earth’s surface have a different albedo – icy and snowy surfaces reflect a lot of radiation and are said to have high albedo, while the ocean absorbs a lot of radiation and is said to have a low albedo.  One of the more surprising facts is that H20, not CO2 or methane has the largest ‘blanket effect’ on the planet.

Anyhow, that’s all for now, but I look forward to learning more!